icon for Home page
icon for Kid's Home page
icon for Digital Collection
icon for Activities
icon for Turns Exhibit
icon for In the Classroom
icon for Chronologies
icon for My Collection

History Lessons By Teachers

Comparing Attitudes: Three American Wars

Created by Sean Gillane

Grade Level(s): high school (10 - 12)
Historical Era(s): Civil War Era 1860 - 1880, Two World Wars 1914 - 1945, Contemporary Era 1945 to present
Content Area(s): Art, US History


front
Draft cylinder

front
Officers of the 44th Massachusetts Regiment Volunteers

Page 41
Civil War Patriotic Covers or Envelopes

front
"A Soldier's Dream"

front
Memorial - 52nd Massachusetts Volunteers

Page 1
Thank you letter from Mrs. Hooper to Miss Wilson for supplies for Civil War soldiers

document
"Soldiers Memorial- Company F 34th Regt. Masssachusetts Infty Vols."

document
"Keep them smiling"- WWI broadside

Page 1
WWII War Ration Book 2

document
"To You- Who Helped Us Win the Army-Navy "E" Ad in Aero Digest by Greenfield Tap and Die Corporation

document
"America's Entire Strength Is Now Concentrated on Our War Effort" ad for GTD from Greenfield Recorder-Gazette newspaper

Page 1
WWII War Ration Book 4

document
"Hangar Queen" ad from Aero Digest for Greenfield Tap and Die Corporation

front
Greenfield Tap and Die Corporation's framed Memorial of WWII company losses

document
"Don't Tread On Us" editorial in The Greenfield Recorder-Gazette newspaper

document
"Counting Our Blessings!" cartoon from The Greenfield Recorder newspaper

document
"Violence Seen Probable in D.C. Demonstration" article from The Greenfield Recorder newspaper

document
"Police, Protesters Clash" article from The Greenfield Recorder newspaper

document
"Quakers Plan More Gifts for Vietnam War Victims" article in The Greenfield Recorder newspaper

document
"War Protest Keeps New England College Campuses in Ferment" article in The Greenfield Recorder newspaper

document
"Students Trying to Convert Congressmen" article in The Greenfield Recorder newspaper

Summary and Objective

Students will understand that public attitudes toward fighting a major war vary, and are expressed through media, whether newspaper articles, art, advertisements, or music. Through completing this activity, students will understand that attitudes varied greatly between the Civil War, World War II, and the Vietnam War. Students will also understand that media and artifacts can stir up emotions which play into the attitudes surrounding a war effort, or anti-war effort. Students will also understand that as students of history and as responsible citizens, we need to recognize differing opinions in evaluating a war effort and the images or impressions we encounter.

Teaching Plan

Step 1. This activity can be completed either in a computer lab or in the classroom as a sequence of "stations" through which the students rotate. The audio portions would need to be available on a teacher's computer. The balance of images can be printed from this activity and links, and distributed around the room. This activity is designed for presentation during a unit on Vietnam.

Step 2. "Do Now/Activator"- Students should brainstorm examples of attitudes toward the current world conflicts, and describe images or speeches they have encountered. The teacher should ask students to briefly discuss what this says about public opinion surrounding the conflicts.

Step 3. Students will act as "reporters" as they roam the room in search of evidence regarding public opinion regarding the Civil War, WW II, and the Vietnam War. Students should be aware of what they see, read, and hear, and how what they observe impacts their feelings about that particular war. As they rotate, students should take notes in a 3-column worksheet with headings for each war.

Step 4. Students should experience a minimum of five artifacts from each war. Once they are done, students should form small (3-4 students) groups and compare what they observed about each war in order to get a full picture of all of the artifacts.

Step 5. The student groups should then create a large organizer using poster paper. In three columns, students should list what they deem important examples of attitudes from all three wars. After compiling these (3-5 examples), students should list how these artifacts impacted them, how they made them feel about each war, and what their reaction was. They should then list their conclusions as to the homefront attitudes toward the war-what efforts were made by the public regarding the war?

Step 6. Students should then, individually, compose three short news articles describing the atmosphere of the times, generated from their fact-finding and group observations. This could be done as homework or in class the following day.

Step 7. Optional debrief: The teacher and students should revisit their beginning activator discussion, and examine evidence of attitudes toward conflict today, and re-examine how media impacts their attitudes toward war.

Web Site: Civil War Song
    http://www.authentichistory.com/1860-1865/sounds/music/19051100_Battle_Hymn_Of_The_Republic-George_Alexander.html

Web Site: WW II Music
    http://www.authentichistory.com/1939-1945/4-music/index.html

Web Site: Vietnam Music
    http://www.sing365.com/music/lyric.nsf/FORTUNATE-SON-lyrics-Creedence-Clearwater-Revival/EB5CA92F255D29B648256AAB0030D12A

Web Site: Kent State Photo
    http://iconicphotos.wordpress.com/2009/06/23/kent-state-shootings/



button for Side by Side Viewingbutton for Glossarybutton for Printing Helpbutton for How to Read Old Documents

 

Home | Online Collection | Things To Do | Turns Exhibit | Classroom | Chronologies | My Collection
About This Site | Site Index | Site Search | Feedback